Stories: Whose are told and whose remains in the margins?
In
the beginning of this module, we had to fill out an anticipation guide. There
were certain statements that we had to agree/disagree with before and after
this module. There
are so many different views, including when it comes to talking about historical
events. There
are so many events that not a lot of us were taught about in school. We hear
stories about people who never lost anything, never really had to fight for
anything, the white side of history. But what about everyone else? Why do we
fail to talk and include them? Other diverse cultures remain in the margins. One
of the statements that stuck out to me was “this teaching pretends that there is a uniform collective story,
which is akin to saying everyone remembers events the same.” I can remember
so many classes where the teacher would be teaching a lesson and a student may
say “well this is what I think about it” giving their point of view and/or
opinions. This student rarely spoke, so I could tell it was important to them
to speak up and be heard. Everyone’s story is different, no matter what is
being talked about. I think it’s important to recognize what we say to others
matters. Whether that be how we teach it to students or what we talk about
during classes now and in the future. We must do better about talking about the
topics and people who aren’t ever talked about. One of the videos we watched
talked about sophisticated collaboration. I think this is crucial to have in our
classrooms for our students to learn about these topics together. Change can
only happen if we do something about it.
Hey Kirsten! I enjoyed reading your post and I agree that we need to make a change about what we are teaching our students. I think a lot of the times students are afraid to speak up about certain topics because teachers will emphasize that this is how it happened and use that mindset of where “everyone remembers events the same.” I think as future teachers we should let our students speak up and let the class have a discussion and everyone can have a chance to speak up about what they know about the event especially when it comes to history. History can be one sided so it will be eye opening to the students to learn about other parts of history that sometimes teachers fail to do. I think that as future educators we should have a goal to let the students discuss topics amongst themselves so that everyone can hear different points of views.
ReplyDeleteHi Risa! It's important our future students know they can have a voice and opinion on things. Although I do think the parts of history we learn in school are vital, there are other events and people that need to be spoken about in an academic setting. We have the ability to allow are students to learn more than what we did in certain classes. Thank you for reading and commenting!
DeleteHi Kirsten, thank you for sharing your thoughts on Stories: Whose are told and whose remains in the margins! I agree there are so many different interpretations of history and I even find that different teachers can teach the same topic from different views. So the question becomes how do we teach all the different views throughout history in the time frame of a school year? I feel like that is really where the struggle is located. There is so much history that somewhere in the education system a group of people got to decide what is important enough to teach. What is important to some is not to others so what is the right answer. I do not have the answer but I would still like to know your thoughts on the questions. Again thank you for allowing me to read your thoughts on this matter, they were very enlightening.
ReplyDeleteHi Bailey! Teaching in a way that isn't one sided can be very challenging. I think my answer to your question would be inclusion. Not every teacher teaches the same or gives the same lesson on something, it's all different. Making sure our students feel they are learning about something that is important to them, but also something completely new to them is essential. Inclusion is vital when it comes to teaching and being in a classroom full of unique people. Thank you for your comment!
DeleteHi Kirsten, I really enjoyed reading your blog this week about margins and how they are created in our world. I completely agree with your statement about how we need to change the way we are teaching our students in the classroom. I also agree about how teachers can all view events and people from history different, but this only makes the learning experience for students more confusing and miscommunicated. Instead of teachers teaching off what they believe and their particular point of view, I believe that they should only speak the facts and save their opinions from themselves in order to offer the best possible education to their students. It is not fair that some teachers get to choose what parts of history they want to teach because all that they are doing is taking away the opportunity for the children to learn about their history and how it changed the world that they live in today. Great job on your blog!
ReplyDelete